Cheap Apartments For Rent In Gary Indiana . 4400 w 23rd ave | gary, in, 46404. On average, section 8 housing choice vouchers pay gary landlords $600 per month towards rent. 1735 W. 5th Ave, Gary, IN 46404 MGM Property Management from mgmpmi.com 624 hanley street, gary, in 46406. As of june 2022, the average apartment rent in gary, in is $623 for a studio, $702 for one bedroom, $853 for two bedrooms, and $1,280 for three bedrooms. 9 for rent by owner near gary.