Cheap Apartments For Rent In Lake Geneva Wi . Explore apartment listings and get details like rental price, floor plans, photos, amenities, and much more. Let apartment finder guide you in the process of finding your new home and getting a great deal! 427 Spring St, Lake Geneva, WI 53147 MLS 1748480 Trulia from www.trulia.com Use our detailed filters to find the perfect place, then get in touch with the property manager. The average rent of $935 per month is just above the state average. See all 57 apartments in lake geneva, wi currently available for rent.